The Hobbit: Chapter 16: A Thief in the Night
The History of The Hobbit, Part Two: Chapter XVI: Divided Loyalties
The History of The Hobbit, Part Two: Timelines and Itinerary
Timeline: Third Age November 2941
1. Why does Thorin not heed Roäc’s wise counsel?
2. What do you think of Bilbo’s plan? Did he betray Thorin?
3. Should Bilbo have accepted Thranduil’s offer to stay in the camp rather than returning to the Mountain?